The Scribbler Publishing Group
No Holds Barred
More than three decades of delving into the Mahoning Valley’s underbelly: Twelve hours after the final edition of The (Youngstown) Vindicator had rolled off the presses on Friday, August 30, 2019, I returned to an eerily silent newsroom that had hummed with life just a short time before. The reality of the demise of the 150-year-old daily newspaper was driven home by the absence of the Saturday crew tasked with “putting out” (newspaper-speak for “publishing”) the Sunday paper. Indeed, only the Commemorative Edition bearing the date Saturday, August 31, 2019, would henceforth serve as a reminder of a glorious era in journalism in the Mahoning Valley.

As I sat in my cubicle looking at the papers scattered over my desks, the stacks of page proofs and the files and boxes of newspaper clippings, I realized I was looking at my life’s work. One folder in particular caught my eye. It was jammed with yellowed newspaper pages featuring some of my Sunday columns spanning more than three decades. I riffled through them and was overcome with a deep sense of sadness over the end of what had been a 40-year relationship with The Vindicator, one of the finest newspapers in the country.
The thought of tossing it all in the dustbin of history was too much to bear.
However, a question arose during this emotional roller coaster ride: What if I were to memorialize some of my best columns in a book, thereby preserving the legacy of The Vindicator as the unparalleled watchdog of the Mahoning Valley, the state of Ohio and the nation?
As the idea took root, another question sprang forth: “Would the publication of such a book be viewed by the public as nothing more than the self-aggrandizing act of an egotistical columnist?” A long, heartfelt conversation with one of the premier editors in the history of the newspaper, Cynthia Rickard, erased any doubts about the rightness of publishing such a book. Cindi had worked for The Vindicator for 41 years and as the night editor had edited many of my Sunday columns. While she didn’t always agree with the hard-edged tone of my commentaries, she acknowledged the need to turn the bright light of press scrutiny on government at all levels.
Cindi served as the editor for the book, and several other veteran journalists, Robert McFerren, Ernie Brown, Jenn Schatzel and Kellie Jones-Cochran, along with Julie Zuckla and Megan Christensen, were part of the team.
Order your copy today
No Holds Barred
More than three decades of delving into the Mahoning Valley’s underbelly.
** Separate orders must be placed when shipping to multiple addresses.
Blog: Delve Deeper
- “Bertram’s Christmas Ode”By (his brow-beaten, unpaid collaborators) Cynthia Rickard & Robert Mcferren (published over his objections) Everyone in Youngstown liked Christmas a lot, but Bertram who lived on the North Side did not. Bertram hated Christmas, the whole Christmas season Now please don’t ask why, no one quite knows the reason It could be his eye patch is pushed in too tight It could be his head isn’t screwed on just right More likely, he’s missing the columns he wrote About lawmakers and presidents he would emote So he gathered them up, forcing colleagues to pick the ones to preserve for all… Read More »“Bertram’s Christmas Ode”
Scribbler Podcast




